Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance is a critical factor in determining a company's success. As consumers increasingly prioritise sustainability and ethical practices, businesses that fall short in ESG risk losing not only customers but also investor confidence. In this blog, we will explore how poor ESG performance can lead to significant customer drop-off and declining investments, and why proper and transparent ESG practices are essential to maintaining long-term financial health.
Consumer Preferences Shifting Toward Sustainability
A growing body of evidence shows that consumers are paying closer attention to sustainability when making purchasing decisions. Nearly 80% of consumers in the Asia-Pacific region, including Australia, now consider sustainability an important factor in their buying behaviour. This market shift means that businesses neglecting ESG practices are at serious risk of losing a significant portion of their customer base.
Supporting this, 60% of global consumers are willing to pay more for environmentally sustainable products. In Australia, where environmental consciousness is on the rise, companies that fail to address ESG issues may see their sales decline as customers move toward brands that demonstrate responsible environmental stewardship. Ignoring sustainability is no longer an option for companies looking to retain customer loyalty and maintain a competitive edge.
Impact on Investor Sentiment
It's not just customers who are taking note of ESG performance—investors are increasingly incorporating ESG metrics into their investment strategies. 88% of institutional investors are now factoring ESG performance into their portfolio analysis (Xue et al., 2023). In Australia, companies with poor ESG ratings face the risk of declining investor confidence. The Australian Sustainable Finance Initiative reported that as much as $3 trillion is at stake if Australian businesses fail to meet sustainability expectations (Xue et al., 2023).
For businesses, this shift in investor sentiment underscores the financial implications of neglecting ESG. When companies fall short of industry expectations for sustainability and governance, they may experience not only a decline in stock prices but also a loss of investor trust and long-term support. As ESG factors become more integrated into mainstream investment criteria, companies that underperform in this area will struggle to attract and retain investors.
Financial Performance Correlation
The link between strong ESG performance and financial success is becoming increasingly clear. Research indicates that companies actively managing and improving their ESG practices can achieve financial returns 5-10% higher than their competitors with poor ESG records (Jucá et al., 2024). Businesses that prioritise sustainability tend to enjoy stronger brand loyalty, lower operational risks, and better access to capital.
In contrast, companies experiencing ESG-related controversies—such as environmental violations or poor labour practices—can suffer immediate and severe financial impacts. In some cases, stock prices can drop by as much as 25% or more when ESG issues become public. This demonstrates that ESG controversies don't just tarnish a company’s reputation—they also have a direct and measurable impact on financial performance.
Reputational Risk and Brand Loyalty
One of the most significant risks associated with poor ESG performance is reputational damage. Studies show that brand loyalty is increasingly tied to a company's ethical practices. A source found that a staggering 76% of consumers would stop purchasing from a company known for irresponsible environmental practices.
As customers become more environmentally and socially conscious, companies with poor ESG reputations face the risk of not only losing customers but also damaging their long-term brand equity. Rebuilding consumer trust after an ESG scandal is incredibly difficult and costly, making it crucial for businesses to prioritise sustainability and transparency in their operations.
Regulatory Pressure and Compliance Costs
Australia’s regulatory landscape is evolving, and companies that fail to comply with ESG regulations could face significant financial penalties. Non-compliance with ESG rules can result in costs that exceed 10% of a company's revenue. With increasing pressure from both consumers and regulators, transparency and accountability in ESG reporting are no longer optional—they are essential for avoiding financial and reputational damage.
Companies that do not prioritise ESG risk hefty fines, legal action, and the potential for long-term financial harm. On the other hand, businesses that embrace transparent ESG practices will be better positioned to navigate the regulatory environment and mitigate financial risks.
Conclusion: Why Proper ESG Practices Matter
In summary, the connection between ESG performance and customer loyalty, as well as investor confidence, is undeniable. Companies that fail to address ESG issues face not only a drop in consumer trust but also a significant decline in financial performance, including diminished investor support and potential legal repercussions.
On the flip side, businesses that invest in sustainability and transparent ESG practices stand to benefit from increased brand loyalty, investor interest, and long-term financial stability. Today’s consumers and investors expect more from companies, and those that fail to meet these expectations will struggle to stay competitive in an evolving market.
By taking proactive steps to improve ESG performance, businesses can protect their reputations, retain customer loyalty, and attract investors who prioritise sustainability. It’s not just a moral imperative—it’s a business obligation.
Ready to Make Your Business More Sustainable?
If you're ready to take the first steps toward making your business more sustainable and transparent, book a free demo with us today. Let us help you start building a step-by-step plan to improve your ESG performance and secure your company’s long-term success.
